🏀 5x5 | Royce Webb

🏀 5x5 | Royce Webb

The Paolo Problem: What Should the Magic Do about Banchero?

Orlando has a big dilemma on its hands. Let's talk about it

Jeremias Engelmann's avatar
Royce Webb's avatar
Jeremias Engelmann and Royce Webb
Jan 09, 2026
∙ Paid
Paolo Banchero: Problem or part of the solution in Orlando? (David Jensen/Getty Images)


Here’s a conversation between the two authors, in which we cover the following:

  • Why Paolo Banchero is falling short in both advanced stats and the eye test

  • The bullish case for Paolo

  • Why the Magic are in a tough spot and what they should do

  • What a Paolo-Giannis trade would look like

Enjoy!


RW: Paolo was the No. 1 pick in the 2022 NBA draft and the nearly unanimous choice for Rookie of the Year. He was an All-Star the next season.

Yet, every season of his four-year career, the Orlando Magic have been better when he’s not on the floor — usually much better.

This has made him the NBA’s new avatar for “eye test vs. advanced stats,” following in the footsteps of Carmelo Anthony.

But now, the narrative and metrics are starting to converge, and it’s suddenly a big topic: Would the Magic be better off without Paolo?

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
Jeremias Engelmann's avatar
A guest post by
Jeremias Engelmann
Basketball analyst. Creator of ESPN's Real Plus-Minus. Formerly with the Phoenix Suns and Dallas Mavericks
Subscribe to Jeremias
© 2026 Royce Webb · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture